I ask this question because it seems to me that we, as songwriters are real experts at naming which one of our creations are bad, so much in fact that for some songwriters, it stops them from creating altogether.
Here are some thoughts I have on this subject.
Now, call me strange, but I’ve never looked at any of my songs as being either good or bad. I just allow them to be.
At the end of the day, my songs can be put into one of two categories:
- Songs I perform
- Songs I don’t perform
Of course the songs that I perform are the songs I’m very comfortable with sharing with the listening public and/or other musicians
However, the songs I don’t perform go into one of two more categories:
- Works in progress (for performance)
- Archived songwriting ideas (for later)
You see, I never throw anything away. Everything that comes from my head is created into something straight away or recycled to be created into something else in the future.
Lets face it, the more songs you write, the more ‘good’ songs you’ll write and for every good song you write there are at least ten ‘bad’ ones lurking in the wings.
So, no matter how much you think your songwriting ideas are bad, write them down anyway. Besides, where does it say in the rules that you have to pitch or perform every song that you write anyway?
If you want to write good songs then writing the occasional bad songs is an inevitable outcome and besides, what really makes a song bad?
A bad song from one songwriter could be another performers treasure. What do you think?
There’ll be some songs you write that are meant to be performed and the other songs will just be the stepping stones towards even more songs.
Can you see where I’m going with this?
When you think about it, the concept of a song being bad is created from a subjective opinion and really, is proclaiming one of your songs as being bad your call anyway?
Here is a exercise to try on yourself. Try deliberately writing a bad song and see how you go. It’s like asking a seasoned musician to play like a beginner.
It’s harder to do than you think. What are your thoughts on this? Let me know what they are.
Until next time, keep on writing,
All About Songwriting